\n
\nNEW DELHI: Swan Telecom promoter Shahid Balwa<\/a> was the among the 2G scam accused who latched on to the CBI director's submission in the Supreme Court on Monday that there were \"conflicting\" views of investigating officers in 2G scam cases and Aircel-Maxis case against former telecom minister Dayanidhi Maran<\/a> and sought the internal notes to be made public to prove their innocence.
\n
\nBalwa was first to be off the block in moving an application requesting the court to provide him with a copy of the sealed cover documents given to the court. The accused were keen on getting the file notings showing \"conflicting\" views out in public to be able to show the trial court that the investigating agency itself was not sure about the impeccability of the evidence in the cases against them.
\n
But a bench of justices HL Dattu and SA Bobde stopped CBI chief Ranjit Sinha<\/a>'s counsel Vikas Singh from revealing how the Aircel-Maxis case proceeded within the corridors of the investigating agency, and the manner in which its chief tried to save the case from being closed.
\n
\nSingh talked of \"conflicting\" views while disputing counsel Prashant Bhushan's claim that the Aircel-Maxis case was treated as a watertight case by the investigating officers but the director was dragging his feet and delaying filing of chargesheet. The court stopped Sinha from revealing internal details, saying it would harm the trial which is in final stages. Singh said it's for this reason that he had submitted the file notings in sealed cover. \"If I am forced to disclose all these things, it is going to help the accused,\" he said and charged Bhushan with forcing him to do so to help the 2G scam accused.
\n
\nSenior advocate Ram Jethmalani said no evidence which could fairly assist the accused in proving their innocence should be suppressed. Both Bhushan and the CBI counsel, senior advocate KK Venugopal, opposed it.
\n
\nThe bench asked both Bhushan and the CBI to respond to Balwa's application by September 24 but sarcastically added: \"He (Balwa) thinks we are going to give it to him!\"
\n
\nThe sarcasm didn't end there. As Jethmalani was insisting on documents being given to the accused, the bench said: \"We will give you every document to the accused, but only after the trial is complete.\"
\n
Giving details of the Aircel-Maxis case, Singh said a myth has been propagated by Bhushan that the investigating officers had built a watertight case but the truth is that most of them had said there was something in favour of the accused and had even closed the case relating to alleged irregularities in the decision of Foreign Investment Promotion Board<\/a> (FIPB).
\n
\nThe decision to close the FIPB case was reversed at the rank of additional director and the director supported reopening of the case, Singh said and expressed his annoyance that despite all this the CBI chief was being accused of wrongdoing.
\n
\n
\n
\n\n<\/body>","next_sibling":[{"msid":42592409,"title":"2G: SC order on whistleblowers' identity raises possibility of inter-agency or intra-CBI tussle","entity_type":"ARTICLE","link":"\/news\/policy\/2g-sc-order-on-whistleblowers-identity-raises-possibility-of-inter-agency-or-intra-cbi-tussle\/42592409","category_name":null,"category_name_seo":"policy"}],"related_content":[],"seoschemas":false,"msid":42619528,"entity_type":"ARTICLE","title":"2G accused seek 'conflicting' files","synopsis":"Swan Telecom promoter Shahid Balwa was the among the 2G scam accused who sought internal notes to be made public to prove innocence.","titleseo":"policy\/2g-accused-seek-conflicting-files","status":"ACTIVE","authors":[{"author_name":"Dhananjay Mahapatra","author_link":"\/author\/18127\/dhananjay-mahapatra","author_image":"https:\/\/etimg.etb2bimg.com\/authorthumb\/18127.cms?width=250&height=250&imgsize=6987","author_additional":{"thumbsize":true,"msid":18127,"author_name":"Dhananjay Mahapatra","author_seo_name":"Dhananjay-Mahapatra","designation":"Senior Editor","agency":false}}],"Alttitle":{"minfo":""},"artag":"TNN","artdate":"2014-09-16 14:55:42","lastupd":"2014-09-16 14:57:33","breadcrumbTags":["policy","Dayanidhi Maran","Foreign Investment Promotion Board","Shahid Balwa","Ranjit Sinha"],"secinfo":{"seolocation":"policy\/2g-accused-seek-conflicting-files"}}" data-authors="[" dhananjay mahapatra"]" data-category-name="Policy" data-category_id="19" data-date="2014-09-16" data-index="article_1">
新德里:天鹅电信启动子Shahid Balwa是在2 g的诈骗指控他关注CBI导演的提交最高法院周一,有“冲突”的观点调查人员在2 g诈骗案件和Aircel-Maxis案件前电信部长供词和寻求内部笔记公开证明他们的清白。
Balwa是第一块在移动应用程序请求法院为他提供密封盖的副本文件给了法院。被告是热衷于获取文件并显示“冲突”的观点在公众能够展示的审判法庭调查机构本身就是不确定的无罪证据的情况下。
但长椅上法官HL Dattu和SA Bobde停止CBI首席Ranjit SinhaVikas辛格的律师从揭示如何Aircel-Maxis走廊内的情况进行调查机构,其主要的方式试图拯救被结案了。
辛格谈到了“冲突”的观点而争论顾问之一声称Aircel-Maxis案例被视为一个水密案件由调查人员但导演拖着沉重的脚步和chargesheet延迟申请。法院阻止Sinha揭示内部细节,称这将损害审判的最后阶段。辛格说,由于这个原因,他提交了文件注意密封盖。“如果我被迫披露所有这些事情,它将帮助被告,”他说,指控Bhushan迫使他这样做帮助2 g诈骗指控。
高级提倡Ram Jethmalani说没有证据表明这可能相当帮助被告证明他们的清白应该抑制。Bhushan和英国工业联合会顾问、高级主KK Venugopal,反对它。
板凳问Bhushan和CBI应对Balwa应用的9月24日但讽刺地说:“他(Balwa)认为我们要给他!”
讽刺并没有结束。像Jethmalani坚持文档给被告,法官说:“我们将给你每个文档被告,但只有在试验完成后。”
给Aircel-Maxis案件的细节,辛格说神话已经被Bhushan传播,调查人员已经建立了一个水密情况但事实是,他们中的大多数说有什么支持被告,甚至关闭此案有关涉嫌违规行为决定的外国投资促进委员会(FIPB)。
决定关闭FIPB案逆转级的额外的主任和主任支持重启的情况下,辛格说,并表示他的烦恼,尽管如此,英国工业联合会首席是被指控的不当行为。
评论
现在评论 阅读评论(1)所有评论
找到这个评论进攻?
下面选择你的理由并单击submit按钮。这将提醒我们的版主采取行动