![\"\"](\"\/\/www.iser-br.com\/Themes\/Release\/images\/responsive\/ettelecom-default.jpg\")
The submissions of the Centre and the UT were opposed before a bench, headed by Justice N V Ramana, by senior lawyers Salman Khurshid and Huzefa Ahmadi who were representing parties seeking restoration of 4G, on grounds such as right to access doctors is an inherent under article 21 (Right to Life) of the Constitution and it's deprivation should be judged in view of the coronavirus<\/a> or Covid-19 pandemic.
They also alleged that the right of children to access schools through the high speed internet<\/a> service have been hampered.
The bench, which also comprised Justices R Subhash Reddy and B R Gavai, heard arguments of both sides including that of Attorney General K K Venugopal and Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, for the Centre and the Union Territory respectively, and reserved the verdict.
During the over 2-hour hearing, held via video conferencing, Venugopal said the government's policy decision should not be questioned as the restriction was meant to protect the entire population of the state and not only patients.
\"Terrorists are being pushed into the country. Yesterday, there were some tragic incident,\" Venugopal said, adding that videos of the troop movements can be shared with the enemy by using 4G and there was no denial of the fact that security of the state was considered while taking such a decision.
He said that fixed line internet was already permitted in the UT and the authorities can keep a check on any terrorist propaganda and urged the court that the PILs be examined by keeping the \"larger public interest of national security\" in mind.
The law officer said sovereignty of the nation and the state was seriously affected due to terrorist activities.
Matters of policy should not be interfered and it must be left to the government, Venugopal said.
Solicitor General Tushar Mehta said that the restrictions were necessary and moreover, internet was working in the UT through land lines which is traceable and cannot be misused for anti-national activities.
Mobile<\/a> phones are used and thrown away, he said, adding that the review committee will take the decision on the restoration of the 4G.
The law officer said initially there was complete lock down and later movement is being allowed to some extent and the decisions are being made at the ground level by persons concerned.
Ahmadi, appearing for one of the petitioners, referred to the orders passed by the UT administration on curbing of internet speed and said nothing substantial can be done by using 2G.
The senior lawyer said that doctors are unable to access information about COVID treatment in the UT, where there was 701 COVID cases as on date.
The right to access information is inherent under Article 21 and deprivation of fundamental rights has to be judged in the light of the fact that there was a pandemic and the rights of persons to access doctors and of children to access schools are restricted, he said.
The bench said there was no dispute with regard to the fact that 4G is very fast as compared to 2G, but the legal question was of balance.
\"There are health concerns and security concerns and the government was raising security concerns,\" the bench said.
It said that the authorities have said that the people can rely on landline broadband connections which are more than one lakh in the UT.
Ahmadi alleged that rights to livelihood and access to telemedicine have been affected and people have been denied the right to connect with their friends and family.
Senior advocate Khurshid said that private schools are under the government directions to provide education via video-conferencing which cannot be provided due to the lack of internet speed
The UT, on its affidavit, said that there has been a weekly review of the situation but none of the review orders or information as available in public domain, the lawyer said.
Earlier, the UT administration, in its affidavit, had said that terror modules operating within Jammu and Kashmir and their handlers from across the border incite people by transmission of fake news.
It had said there were well founded apprehensions of misuse of internet for propagation of terror activities and incitement through the circulation of inflammatory material - particularly fake videos and photos as also co-ordination of activities that are inimical to security and public order.
The submissions were made in response to PILs including the one filed by Foundation for Media Professionals<\/a> seeking restoration of 4G internet services in the Union Territory in view of prevailing Covid-19 pandemic.
Prior to this, the top court had issued notices to the Centre and Jammu and Kashmir administration on the PILs seeking restoration of 4G internet services in the Union territory.<\/body>","next_sibling":[{"msid":75546032,"title":"Open to third-party audit of user data collection: Manu Jain","entity_type":"ARTICLE","link":"\/news\/open-to-third-party-audit-of-user-data-collection-manu-jain\/75546032","category_name":null,"category_name_seo":"telecomnews"}],"related_content":[],"msid":75546118,"entity_type":"ARTICLE","title":"Centre, J-K oppose in SC pleas for 4G network, say high speed net can be used to track troops","synopsis":"They also alleged that the right of children to access schools through the high speed internet service have been hampered.","titleseo":"telecomnews\/centre-j-k-oppose-in-sc-pleas-for-4g-network-say-high-speed-net-can-be-used-to-track-troops","status":"ACTIVE","authors":[],"analytics":{"comments":0,"views":250,"shares":0,"engagementtimems":180000,"url":"https:\/\/ettelecom.indiatimes.com\/telecomnews\/centre-j-k-oppose-in-sc-pleas-for-4g-network-say-high-speed-net-can-be-used-to-track-troops\/articleshow\/75546118.cms"},"Alttitle":{"minfo":""},"artag":"PTI","artdate":"2020-05-05 08:36:42","lastupd":"2020-05-05 08:39:04","breadcrumbTags":["4G network","high speed internet","Foundation for Media Professionals","J-K 4G network","Mobile","coronavirus","Internet"],"secinfo":{"seolocation":"telecomnews\/centre-j-k-oppose-in-sc-pleas-for-4g-network-say-high-speed-net-can-be-used-to-track-troops"}}" data-authors="[" "]" data-category-name="" data-category_id="" data-date="2020-05-05" data-index="article_1">
读到
中心的提交和UT反对在长椅上之前,由正义N V拉,由资深律师萨尔曼得以和Huzefa艾哈迈迪代表政党寻求恢复4 g,理由如权利访问医生下一个固有的宪法第二十一条(生存权)这是剥夺应该判断的冠状病毒或Covid-19大流行。
他们还声称,孩子的权利通过高速访问学校互联网服务受到阻碍。
替补席上,也由大法官Subhash Reddy和B R R Gavai,听到双方的论点包括司法部长K K Venugopal和总检察长印度梅赫塔分别为中心和欧盟领土,并保留判决。
在两个小时的听力,通过视频会议举行,Venugopal说,政府的决策不应该质疑限制是为了保护整个国家的人口不仅病人。
“恐怖分子正被推向全国。昨天,有一些悲惨的事件,”Venugopal补充说,军事行动的视频可以共享与敌人使用4 g和没有否认的事实状态被认为是安全而采取这样的决定。
他说,固定线路网络已经允许UT,当局可以遏制任何恐怖主义宣传,并敦促法院得利)进行检查,保持“国家安全”更大的公共利益。
法律官员说国家和国家的主权是严重影响由于恐怖主义活动。
重要的政策不应该干扰和它必须离开政府,Venugopal说。
副检察长Mehta说,印度央行的限制是必要的,此外,互联网正在UT通过固定电话跟踪,不能滥用反国家活动。
移动手机使用和丢弃,他补充说,审查委员会将决定恢复4 g。
法律官员说最初完全锁定,之后运动在某种程度上被允许和决策是由有关人员在地面。
艾哈迈迪,出现的上访者,指的是订单通过的UT管理控制的互联网速度和没说什么实质性的可以通过使用2 g。
资深律师表示,医生无法访问信息COVID治疗UT,那里有701 COVID病例和日期。
正确的获取信息是固有在第二十一条和剥夺基本权利必须判断的事实有一个流行和人的权利访问医生和儿童进入学校的限制,他说。
板凳上说没有纠纷对4 g是非常快和2 g相比,但平衡的法律问题。
“有健康问题和安全问题,政府提高安全问题,”法官说。
它说,当局说,人们可以依靠有线宽带连接的多个十万的UT。
艾哈迈迪称生计和访问远程医疗的权利受到影响,人们一直否认与他们的朋友和家人。
高级提倡得以说,私立学校是根据政府的方向通过视频会议提供教育不能提供由于缺少互联网的速度
UT,其证词说,有每周回顾的情况但没有审查订单或信息在公共领域,律师说。
早些时候,但政府在其证词,曾经说过,在查谟和克什米尔恐怖模块操作和处理程序从边境煽动人的假新闻的传播。乐动扑克
就说有成立忧惧滥用互联网传播恐怖活动和煽动通过炎性物质的循环——尤其是假视频和照片也不利于协调活动安全和公共秩序。
提交是在响应得利)包括一提起的基础媒体专业人士寻求恢复4 g网络服务在欧盟境内的主流Covid-19大流行。
在此之前,最高法院发布了通知中心和查谟和克什米尔政府得利寻求恢复4 g网络服务联盟的领土。
评论
现在评论 阅读评论(1)所有评论
找到这个评论进攻?
下面选择你的理由并单击submit按钮。这将提醒我们的版主采取行动