India will auction 5G spectrum later this month. There is much debate on whether mobile players and space broadband<\/a> players can coexist in the mmWave frequency and whether the government should auction spectrum for satellite services. In an interaction with ETTelecom’s Mansi Taneja, Cristian Gomez<\/a>, Senior Director - Government & Regulatory Affairs, Asia Pacific at Viasat<\/a> talks about global learnings on 5G mmWave band<\/a>, balanced spectrum allocation and Viasat’s plans for Indian market.
Globally, which geographies offer 5G services on mmWave band? Have they been successful?
<\/strong>
The 5G millimetre wave is not being offered anywhere in a meaningful way to the mass market with any level of success. There are some deployments in three countries - US, Japan, Singapore but these are small scale deployments only for venue-specific applications, such as hotspots inside malls.
Even in the US which was the first country to first push for 5G mmWave, there is independent industry data that shows that the total average time consumers connected to a 5G mmWave is less than 1% of the time across all three US mobile networks.
5G mmWave relies on existing and new construction of massive amounts of fiber optic infrastructure to connect 5G mmWave cell sites to achieve the target download speeds. This is a preclusive element for most countries to make 5G mmWave financially viable, given that most countries in the world do not have the levels of fiber deployments of the US, Japan and Singapore. For this reason, mobile operators and governments have globally shifted their focus from 5G mmWave to 5G in the mid band spectrum.
5G mmWave is unlikely to be transformational in the rest of the world because of the preclusive capital investments required and the fact that 5G mmWave cannot physically be used to provide coverage to the mass consumer.
Also, Apple – the largest smartphone manufacturer in the world – has scrapped 5G mmWave from their new version of iPhone SE, on that basis that 5G mmWave adds hardware costs that then need to be passed on to consumers which aren’t willing to spend when the reality is 5G mmWave isn’t available widely or considering that in the majority of markets 5G mmWave will never be an economically viable option.
What are your plans to offer services in the Indian market? Will you offer services in partnership with an Indian telco?
<\/strong>
Viasat is progressing very well in the construction of the ViaSat-3 global fleet of ultra-high throughput GEO satellites, offering the highest capacity in the market: over 1 Tbps of throughput per satellite, with speeds between 300 Mbps to 1 Gbps. The ViaSat-3 fleet will have its own dedicated satellite for Asia Pacific, which will cover India. We are launching the first satellite at the end of this year to cover the Americas region, followed by the EMEA and the Asia Pacific satellites at 6-month intervals.
Through this global fleet, Viasat will provide the lowest cost per Gbps per month available in the market – to connect everyone, everywhere across land, sea, and air. We also have the ViaSat-4 project underway that will increase this global capacity by 5 times, and have our own LEO satellite project under development.
Viasat has substantial R&D activity in India, and the ground infrastructure systems we manufacture are available to local players. Viasat is open to partnership options with India-based telcos.
Is a balanced spectrum allocation possible between space broadband players and mobile players in the mmWave band?
<\/strong>
A balanced spectrum allocation is very much possible and the example of Europe, Australia and over 100 countries proves it. Europe decided to implement 5G mmWave in alignment with the globally agreed allocation of spectrum bands by the ITU, making 26 GHz available for 5G and the 28 GHz for space-based broadband. This approach balances well the fact that 5G mmWave is nascent and the 26 GHz provides spectrum to accommodate both mobile operators and 5G private networks<\/a> in the same mmWave band.
This approach also takes advantage of the beneficial economics of satellite broadband<\/a> in 28 GHz which can cover entire countries with one or few satellites and provide broadband to all including aviation, maritime and ground transport.
What have been global processes for auction of spectrum in mmwave band for satellite firms?<\/strong>
Spectrum auctions have been used now for decades. The rationale behind it: the exclusive allocation of a limited resource, at a fair price, where demand exceeds supply. If this economic principle is not present in the spectrum band concerned, the auction fails (no bids or unsold spectrum).
Spectrum allocation via auction cannot be applied to satellite firms simply because this very simple economic principle does not fit space-based infrastructure: the entire global satellite spectrum resources is shared and no satellite operator in the world holds exclusive spectrum rights.
Thousands of satellites all share the same spectrum and there are only a few satellite bands in comparison to the number of mobile bands. Satellites also do not serve just one country, satellites are designed and deployed to serve entire world regions across many country borders, hence the use of satellite spectrum is coordinated globally by the ITU.
This precludes satellite spectrum from being owned by any given company, it is a globally shared resource, and therefore auctions are not a widespread practice in space-based spectrum uses such as satellite communications.
Because of this major difference, mobile spectrum being exclusively owned by each mobile operator and satellite spectrum being globally shared, competition concerns are not pertinent between the two.
Do you see a case for auction of spectrum in this mmwave band - for satellite firms - in India?<\/strong>
Mobile operators pay for exclusive access to keep others out of the market. Space-based communications make shared use of the spectrum resource globally, and because satellite companies share the same resource, competition is even more intense in the satellite segment.
Governments recognise this and this is why auction pioneers like New Zealand and the rest of the world continue to embrace such a competitive environment in the satellite sector and only use administrative spectrum mechanisms for satellite services.
Big firms such as OneWeb, Amazon, Starlink have plans to launch services in the Indian market.What kind of potential and opportunities do you see in the Indian satcom<\/a> market?
<\/strong>
The potential of the companies mentioned depends on their long-term economic viability and also their ability to calibrate a responsible and equitable use of the LEO orbit. The cost of launching, operating, developing, disposing but most importantly, replacing LEO mega-constellations of thousands of satellites every 5 years is a major factor for consideration. Those costs are in the end passed on to consumers.
Another major consideration is for India to ensure its own long-term access to the LEO orbit for its own LEO uses.
<\/body>","next_sibling":[{"msid":92869800,"title":"Samsung led handset market with 23% value share in H1 2022","entity_type":"ARTICLE","link":"\/news\/samsung-led-handset-market-with-23-value-share-in-h1-2022\/92869800","category_name":null,"category_name_seo":"telecomnews"}],"related_content":[],"msid":92869228,"entity_type":"ARTICLE","title":"Co-existence between terrestrial & space broadband players possible: Viasat executive","synopsis":"Even in the US which was the first country to first push for 5G mmWave, there is independent industry data that shows that the total average time consumers connected to a 5G mmWave is less than 1% of the time across all three US mobile networks.","titleseo":"telecomnews\/co-existence-between-terrestrial-space-broadband-players-possible-viasat-executive","status":"ACTIVE","authors":[{"author_name":"Mansi Taneja","author_link":"\/author\/479255290\/mansi-taneja","author_image":"https:\/\/etimg.etb2bimg.com\/authorthumb\/479255290.cms?width=100&height=100","author_additional":{"thumbsize":true,"msid":479255290,"author_name":"Mansi Taneja","author_seo_name":"mansi-taneja","designation":"Associate Editor","agency":false}}],"analytics":{"comments":0,"views":1043,"shares":0,"engagementtimems":3439000},"Alttitle":{"minfo":""},"artag":"ETTelecom","artdate":"2022-07-14 12:30:13","lastupd":"2022-07-28 13:12:02","breadcrumbTags":["viasat","interview","cristian gomez","satcom","5G mmWave band","satcom industry","5G private networks","broadband","satellite broadband","etsatcom"],"secinfo":{"seolocation":"telecomnews\/co-existence-between-terrestrial-space-broadband-players-possible-viasat-executive"}}" data-news_link="//www.iser-br.com/news/co-existence-between-terrestrial-space-broadband-players-possible-viasat-executive/92869228">