\n
\nOthers such as payment provider PayU, owned by South African media conglomerate Naspers, has sought ‘data mirroring’ or datastorage in other locations besides India, to avoid global payment networks from being disrupted.
\n
\n“(There is) no reason why companies should be opposed to the order since most countries such as China, Russia and many countries in Europe require companies to not only store data locally but also process it within the country,” said Kiran Vasireddy, chief operating officer for the payments business of Paytm, which has been storing user data within India even before the Reserve Bank of India mandated it in April.
\n
\nFlipkart-owned PhonePe, which also stores data locally, expects no disruption in operations from the RBI mandate.
\n
\n“India is emerging as a huge democratically open digital economy and it has opened doors for any player to come and operate here, so it’s important that there are right safeguards to protect consumer interests in the long run,” Hemant Gala, head of payments and banking relations of PhonePe told ET. RBI’s directive in April directed all digital payment companies operating in India to set up data storage facilities within the country by October.
\n
\nWhile the payments ecosystem has grown in India, it needs “unfettered supervisory access” to the transaction data to ensure better monitoring of the network.
\n
\n
\n
\nOthers such as payment provider PayU, owned by South African media conglomerate Naspers, has sought ‘data mirroring’ or datastorage in other locations besides India, to avoid global payment networks from being disrupted.
\n
\n“(There is) no reason why companies should be opposed to the order since most countries such as China, Russia and many countries in Europe require companies to not only store data locally but also process it within the country,” said Kiran Vasireddy, chief operating officer for the payments business of Paytm, which has been storing user data within India even before the Reserve Bank of India mandated it in April.
\n
\nFlipkart-owned PhonePe, which also stores data locally, expects no disruption in operations from the RBI mandate.
\n
\n“India is emerging as a huge democratically open digital economy and it has opened doors for any player to come and operate here, so it’s important that there are right safeguards to protect consumer interests in the long run,” Hemant Gala, head of payments and banking relations of PhonePe told ET. RBI’s directive in April directed all digital payment companies operating in India to set up data storage facilities within the country by October.
\n
\nWhile the payments ecosystem has grown in India, it needs “unfettered supervisory access” to the transaction data to ensure better monitoring of the network.
\n
\n
India, the last major open market for internet<\/a> companies, has seen global firms launch digital payment platforms such as Google Tez, Amazon Pay, and WhatsApp to tap the growing opportunity in the country. Indo-US business advocacy groups such as the USIBC and US-India Strategic Partnership Forum (USISPF) have also raised concerns with authorities over the RBI’s directive.
\n
\nSusan Ritchie, vice president of Technology, Media, and Telecommunications, USISPF, said “The best course of action is to allow time until the global companies are able to conduct their reviews on impact of this order.”
\n
\nNot all global firms subscribe to the view.
\n
\nRajan Anandan, vice president for Google India and South East Asia, told ET recently that the company follows local laws and local legislation, so whatever India decides it will “comply” with it.
\n
\nNASSCOM RAISES CONCERNS<\/strong>
\nOn Thursday, technology lobby group Nasscom has also expressed its concerns in a representation sent to RBI over the mandate. The grouping which consists of members both India-based and from global corporations, has opposed the central bank mandate, sources told ET.
\n
\n“This is not just a payments issue. It hits global outsourcing. It may not be feasible for many companies to replicate systems in India. This move will also hit fraud mitigation,” said one of the people privy to details of Nasscom’s stand.
\n
\nDigital payments provider PayU India is asking for data replication — the ability to store both within India and another location.
\n
\n“Global companies often exchange best practices or release new products based on different markets. For example, we may want to use a checkout page for PayU India that has been developed in another
\n
\nmarket, and needs to be first tested based on user data. Restricting movement of data can make this difficult,” said Amrish Rau, CEO of PayU India.
\n
\nAmerican technology giant IBM has also cautioned that any sort of protectionism is often reciprocal.
\n
\n“In the digital world, like any other natural resource, flow of data is akin to ‘digital trade agreements’. Like any other form of trade, protectionism is often reciprocal — which means in steady state, restrictions apply both ways,” said Karan Bajwa, managing director, IBM India Pvt Ltd.
\n
\n“A unique partnership between policy makers, business leaders and citizens, led by government will be able to build the future of work and life in the age of data. It is with this view that we encourage carefully designed ‘digital trade agreements’ on data, as opposed to simplistic policies that have a detrimental impact on innovation.”
\n
\nLegal experts are of the view that RBI’s move is knee jerk and could hurt the multinational payment firms in their business in India.
\n
\n“The RBI’s decision represents India’s first significant policy move towards data localisation, and appears to be a knee-jerk reaction to several high-profile privacy breaches that has captivated the global media,” said Probir Roy Chowdhury, partner at law firm J Sagar Associates.
\n
\n“In an era of cloud computing and interconnectivity, physical access is of little relevance to the security of electronic data. On the contrary, forcing multinational companies to maintain numerous decentralised data centres makes it harder for these companies to exercise control and ensure adequate security,” he said.
\n\n<\/body>","next_sibling":[{"msid":64327445,"title":"NIC sets up cloud-enabled National Data Centre in Bhubaneswar","entity_type":"ARTICLE","link":"\/news\/nic-sets-up-cloud-enabled-national-data-centre-in-bhubaneswar\/64327445","category_name":null,"category_name_seo":"telecomnews"}],"related_content":[],"msid":64327533,"entity_type":"ARTICLE","title":"Digital payments industry divided over data order","synopsis":"Local giants like Paytm and Flipkart have backed the move, while global technology firms have cautioned against reciprocal action.","titleseo":"telecomnews\/digital-payments-industry-divided-over-data-order","status":"ACTIVE","authors":[{"author_name":"Surabhi Agarwal","author_link":"\/author\/479241991\/surabhi-agarwal","author_image":"https:\/\/etimg.etb2bimg.com\/authorthumb\/479241991.cms?width=100&height=100&hid=268","author_additional":{"thumbsize":false,"msid":479241991,"author_name":"Surabhi Agarwal","author_seo_name":"surabhi-agarwal","designation":"Correspondent","agency":false}},{"author_name":"Mugdha Variyar","author_link":"\/author\/479245129\/mugdha-variyar","author_image":"https:\/\/etimg.etb2bimg.com\/authorthumb\/479245129.cms?width=100&height=100&hid=268","author_additional":{"thumbsize":true,"msid":479245129,"author_name":"Mugdha Variyar","author_seo_name":"mugdha-variyar","designation":"Assistant Editor - Consumer Internet","agency":false}}],"Alttitle":{"minfo":""},"artag":"ET Bureau","artdate":"2018-05-26 08:45:20","lastupd":"2018-05-26 08:47:53","breadcrumbTags":["Digital transactions","paytm","phonepe","Flipkart","e-payments","Internet","India"],"secinfo":{"seolocation":"telecomnews\/digital-payments-industry-divided-over-data-order"}}" data-news_link="//www.iser-br.com/news/digital-payments-industry-divided-over-data-order/64327533">