独家
SC拒绝继续执行CCI对谷歌的订单
谷歌一直声称，它在过去15年里一直在运营Android移动平台，而这些由反垄断令指示的“远反应性变化”将对它、设备制造商、印度消费者、应用程序开发者和更广泛的印度经济造成“持久和无法弥补的伤害”。
由首席大法官D Y Chandrachud领导的法庭向谷歌的高级律师AM Singhvi提出了这些问题，谷歌曾对国家公司法上诉法庭(NCLAT1月4日，印度竞争委员会(Competition Commission of India)以涉嫌反竞争行为为由，对这家科技巨头处以1337.76亿卢比的罚款。此案将于周三进行进一步审理。
副检察长R Venkataraman代表CCI和高级律师Mukul Rohatgi出庭OSLabs技术他告诉法官，这家科技巨头歧视“像我们这样的第三世界国家”，给了我们不同的待遇。“欧盟已经认定谷歌滥用支配地位，”ASG表示。
谷歌要求撤销CCI的调查结果、指示和处罚，称该反垄断监管机构的命令“明显错误”，忽视了印度的竞争现实、其支持竞争的商业模式，以及为所有利益相关者创造的利益。
到1月19日，这家Alphabet子公司必须改变在印度营销Android平台的方式。
谷歌在SC文件中说，由于CCI订单，将不得不修改与1100家设备制造商的合同
在向最高法院提起的上诉中，这家搜索引擎巨头表示，印度竞争委员会要求其改变安卓生态系统的命令，将要求该公司“对已经存在了14-15年的安卓移动平台进行深远的改变”，并将对谷歌、设备制造商、印度消费者、应用程序开发者和更广泛的印度经济造成“持久和不可弥补的伤害”。
12月4日，NCLAT以“缺乏紧迫性”为由拒绝维持反垄断监管机构的命令，因为该公司花了两个月的时间提出上诉，并要求谷歌在三周内缴纳10%的罚款。
该公司声称，调查该公司指控的CCI总干事“不加思考”地复制粘贴了外国当局决定的结论，“受到质疑的命令充满了实质性、分析性和程序性错误，除其他外，包括忽视了无罪证据、印度原始设备制造商和开发商的声明……”
上诉称，这些错误导致委员会做出了“有悖常理和不正确的”调查结果。
10月20日，CCI对谷歌进行了处罚，理由是该公司涉嫌利用其在在线搜索和Android应用商店等市场的主导地位。它问互联网主要制止各种不公平的商业行为，并规定了八项纠正措施谷歌玩需要实现。据谷歌报道，这一决定将使印度用户面临前所未有的安全风险，并使印度的Android设备更加昂贵。谷歌于12月20日违反CCI命令接触NCLAT。
![\"SC](\"https:\/\/st.etb2bimg.com\/Themes\/Release\/images\/responsive\/ettelecom-default.jpg\")
<\/figure>Refusing to stay the CCI<\/a>\u2019s order that asked Google<\/a> to make changes by January 19 to its Android ecosystem<\/a>, the Supreme Court on Monday asked the search engine giant to explain on Wednesday if it is \u201cwilling to put the same regime in India as it did abroad\u201d and if the anti-trust directions are \u201cinconsistent with the steps it had taken?\u201dA bench led by Chief Justice D Y Chandrachud posed these queries to senior counsel AM Singhvi, appearing for Google, which has challenged the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal\u2019s (NCLAT<\/a>) January 4 order that refused to stay a Rs 1,337.76 crore penalty imposed on the technology giant by the Competition Commission of India for alleged anti-competitive practices. The case will be taken up for further hearing on Wednesday.
Additional Solicitor General R Venkataraman, appearing for CCI and senior counsel Mukul Rohatgi, on behalf of OSLabs Technology<\/a>, told the bench that the tech giant was discriminating the \u201cthird world country like us\u201d and giving us a different treatment. \u201cThe European Union<\/a> has already held Google to be in abuse of having dominant position,\u201d the ASG said.
<\/div><\/div>Google has been claiming that it had been operating the Android mobile platform for last 15 years and these \u201cfar-reacting changes\u201d as directed by the anti-trust order will lead to \u201clasting and irreparable harm\u201d to it, device manufacturers, Indian consumers, app developers, and the wider Indian economy.
Seeking quashing of the CCI\u2019s findings, directions and the penalty, Google said the antitrust watchdog\u2019s order was \u201cpatently erroneous\u201d and ignored the reality of competition in India, its procompetitive business model, and the benefits created for all stakeholders.
By January 19, the Alphabet subsidiary has to make changes to the way it markets the Android platform in India.
Seeking quashing of the CCI\u2019s findings, directions and the penalty, Google said the antitrust watchdog\u2019s order was \u201cpatently erroneous\u201d and ignored the reality of competition in India, its procompetitive business model, and the benefits created for all stakeholders.
By January 19, the Alphabet subsidiary has to make changes to the way it markets the Android platform in India.